
This Washington Post article the other day reported on a remarkable assertion by the Recording Industry Association of America:
“The industry maintains that it is illegal for someone who has legally purchased a CD to transfer that music into his computer.”
So I assume that the RIAA will soon be going after Apple, because all those iPods out there are facilitating illegal behavior as people dump their CD collections onto their computers and into their iPods. They’ll also be going after Microsoft and the Zune, not to mention every other seller of MP3 players out there.
Oh, and let’s not forget the makers of USB turntables: If it’s illegal to transfer a CD onto one’s computer, it’s undoubtedly illegal to transfer cassette tapes and vinyl records.
Of course, the RIAA won’t do this. They’re more interested in making examples of people and winning high-profile cases like this one, in which a woman was ordered to pay $222,000 to Capitol Records for downloading and swapping two dozen songs.
This will all probably get worse before it gets better. Ultimately, some level of common sense needs to prevail. It’s common sense that one shouldn’t upload copyrighted material for dozens, hundreds, or thousands to download for free. But it’s also common sense that if I have a CD, I should be able to listen to it on any device I wish, whether that’s a CD player or an iPod.
Somewhere in the middle, the RIAA and the general public need to come to an understanding: The RIAA needs to acknowledge that they can’t maintain absolute and total control over everything the public does with the music they buy, and the public needs to acknowledge that there really are common-sense limitations to what can be done with the copyrighted material they purchase.